DOI: https://doi.org/10.37222/2524-0331-2021-11(29)-9
Roman Blikharskyi
SCIENTIFIC STATUS OF UKRAINIAN THEOLOGICAL JOURNALS OF INTERWAR GALICIA
Abstract:
The present article deals with the phenomenon of religious magazines published during the 20th and early twentieth centuries in Galicia, which are dedicated to theological issues. The current criteria for scientific periodicals have been outlined, and the status of theology as a scientific discipline in Ukraine has been determined. The «location» of the theological journals Bohosloviia and Analecta Ordinis S. Basilii Magni in the system of Ukrainian scientific periodicals in particular and on the intellectual map of Ukrainian science in general has been determined.
Historical references to the founding of the Scientific Theological Society in Lviv, whose publication was the Bohosloviia journal (1923– 1939, 1943), have been presented. The prehistory of the beginning of the scientific publication Analecta Ordinis S. Basilii Magni (1924–1935) of the Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church on the initiative of the monastic order of the Order of St. Basil the Great has been highlighted.
The content-thematic model of the journals Bohosloviia and Analecta Ordinis S. Basilii Magni has been analyzed. The specifics of their coverage of specialized and general scientific topics have been considered. Based on the selected evaluation criteria of the scientific periodicals, the functions of the studied journals have been outlined. The significance of these theological scientific journals for the establishment of theology as a professional scientific discipline in modern Ukraine has been clarified.
Keywords: scientific periodicals, religious journals, theology, Analecta Ordinis S. Basilii Magni, Bohosloviia, Galicia, interbellum.
References:
1. Akredytatsiia bohoslovia yak nauky v Ukraini: novi perspektyvy i vyklyky (RISU) [Accreditation of theology as a science in Ukraine: new perspectives and challenges (RISU)]. Ukrainian Catholic University. Retrieved from https://ucu.edu.ua/en/news/akredytatsiya-bohoslovya-yak-nauky-vukrajini-novi-perspektyvy-i-vyklyky-risu/. (in Ukr.).
2. Bereha, V. V. «Trudy Kyivskoi dukhovnoi akademii»: istoriia i suchasnist [Proceedings of the Kyiv Theological Academy: history and modernity].
Retrieved from http://kdais.kiev.ua/trudykda/. (in Ukr.).
3. Blikharskyi, R. (2016). Dylema zitknen ta shliakhy yednannia: antahonizm nauky i relihii na storinkakh chasopysu «Bohosloviia» (Lviv, 1923– 1939 rr.) [The dilemma of conflicts and ways of unity: Antagonism of
Science and Religion in the «Bohosloviia» journal (Lviv, 1923–1939)], Zbirnyk prats Naukovo-doslidnoho instytutu presoznavstva, Lviv, vyp. 6, s. 287–297. (in Ukr.).
4. (1923). «Bohoslovske Naukove Tovarystvo». Statuty [«Bohoslovske Naukove Tovarystvo» Statutes], Bohosloviia, Lviv, t. I, kn. 3/4, s. 340–346. (in Ukr.).
5. Bohoslovsko-fylosofskyi zhurnal «Vera y Razum» [Theological and Philosophical journal «Vera y Razum»]. Retrieved from http://www.eparchia. kharkov.ua/statposts/112. (in Ukr.).
6. Boiko, A. (2013). «Trudy Kyivskoi Dukhovnoi Akademii» (1997–2012 rr.) – tradytsii, novatorstvo, problemy, typolohiia [«Trudy Kyivskoi Dukhovnoi Akademii» (1997–2012) – traditions, innovation, problems, typology], Ukrainska periodyka: istoriia i suchasnist: dop. ta povidoml. odynadtsiatoi Vseukr. nauk.-teoret. konf. 29–30 lystop., Lviv, s. 199–204. (in Ukr.).
7. Vavryk, M. (1974). Do postannia pershoi serii «Zapysok» Chyna sv. Vasyliia Velykoho (1924–1948) [To the founding of the first series «Zapysky» Chyna sv. Vasyliia Velykoho (1924–1948)], Analecta OSBM, Rome, t. ІХ, vyp. 1/4, s. 1–18. (in Ukr.).
8. (1923). Vid Redaktsii [Editorial], Bohosloviia, Lviv, t. I, kn. 1, s. 1–2. (in Ukr.).
9. Volynskyi blahovisnyk: shchorichnyi bohoslovsko-istoyrchnyi naukovyi zhurnal Volynskoi pravoslavnoi bohoslovskoi akademii PTsU [Volynskyi blahovisnyk: annual theological-historical scientific journal by Volyn Orthodox Theological Academy of the Orthodox Church of Ukraine]. Retrieved from http://vb.vpba.edu.ua/ua/general-information. (in Ukr.).
10. Havano, I. (2004). «Bohosloviia», Entsyklopediia suchasnoi Ukrainy: u 30 t., Kyiv, t. 3, s. 149. (in Ukr.).
11. Hrushevskyi, M. (1905). Arystarkh Kryzhanovskyi, Zapysky Naukovoho tovarystva im. Shevchenka, t. 68, kn. 6, s. 8–9. (in Ukr.).
12. Dobko, T. Zaversheno zmahannia za vyznannia bohoslovia naukoiu [The competition for the recognition of theology as a science is over]. Ukrainian Catholic University. Retrieved from https://ucu.edu.ua/en/news/zaver sheno-zmahannya-za-vyznannya-bohoslovya-naukoyu/. (in Ukr.).
13. (1926). Zahalni Zbory B.N.T. [General Meeting of BNT], Bohosloviia,
t. IV, kn. 3, s. 323–325. (in Ukr.).
14. (1928). Zahalni Zbory B.N.T. [General Meeting of BNT], Bohosloviia,
t. VI, kn. 1/2, s. 118–119. (in Ukr.).
15. (1925). Zapysky Chyna sv. Vasyliia Velykoho [Analecta Ordinis S. Basilii Magni], Bohosloviia, t. III, kn. 1/2, s. 169. (in Ukr.).
16. Zelinska, N. V. (2013). Ukrainska naukova periodyka: pohliad z perspektyvy i na perspektyvu [Ukrainian scientific periodicals: perspective view and view on the perspective], Ukrainska periodyka: istoriia i suchasnist: dop. ta povidoml. odynadtsiatoi Vseukr. nauk.-teoret. konf., Lviv, s. 56–64. (in Ukr.).
17. (1923). Zizd profesoriv bohosloviv vsikh dietsezii halytskoi provintsii i osnovane «Naukovoho Bohoslovskoho Tovarystva» [Congress of professors of theologians of all dioceses of the Galician province and the foundation of «Naukove Bohoslovske Tovarystvo»], Bohosloviia, t. I, kn. 1, s. 91–93. (in Ukr.).
18. Yosyf, arkhiep. (1943). Po dvolitnii perervi [After a two-year break], Bohosloviia, t. XVII–XX, kn. 2/4, s. 91–93. (in Ukr.).
19. Kapral, M. M., Yas, O. V. (2010). Zapysky Chyna sv. Vasyliia Velykoho [Analecta Ordinis S. Basilii Magni], Entsyklopediia suchasnoi Ukrainy: u 30 t., Kyiv, t. 10, s. 233. (in Ukr.).
20. Komarytsia, M. (2003). Bohosloviia, Ukrainski chasopysy Lvova 1848– 1939 rr.: ist.-bibliohr. doslidzh.: u 3 t., 4 kn., Lviv, t. 3, kn. 1: 1920–1928, s. 296–304. (in Ukr.).
21. Komarytsia, M. (2003). Zapysky Chyna Sv. Vasyliia Velykoho, Ukrainski chasopysy Lvova 1848–1939 rr.: ist.-bibliohr. doslidzh.: u 3 t., 4 kn., Lviv, t. 3, kn. 1: 1920–1928, s. 293–398. (in Ukr.).
22. Kravcheniuk, O. (1994). Yepyskop Yosyf Botsian (U 115-richchia yoho narodyn), Patriarkhat: hreko-katolytske analitychne vydannia, no. 9(285). Retrieved from http://www.patriyarkhat.org.ua/statti-zhurnalu/epyskopjosyf-botsyan/. (in Ukr.).
23. Kravchuk, A. (2000). Indeks ukrainskoi katolytskoi periodyky Halychyny 1871–1942, Lviv, 536 s. (in Ukr.).
24. Kryshtalovych, U. (1996). Lysty Ivana Yosafata Skrutenia do Romana Lukania [Letters of Ivan Josafat Skruten to Roman Lukan], Ukraina moder na, Lviv, ch. 1, s. 172–185. (in Ukr.).
25. Lozynskyi, M. (2006). Naukove vydannia – Zapysky Chynu sviatoho Vasyliia Velykoho [Scientific publication – Analecta Ordinis S. Basilii Magni], Visnyk Lvivskoho universytetu, Lviv, vyp. 28, s. 204–206, seriia: Zhurnalistyka. (in Ukr.).
26. Myzak, N. (2013). Diialnist Bohoslovskoho naukovoho tovarystva Ukrains koi hreko-katolytskoi tserkvy u 1923–1939 rr. [Activities of the Theological Scientific Society of the Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church in 1923– 1939], Relihiia ta Sotsium, no. 3/4, s. 109–117. (in Ukr.).
27. Muzychka, I. (1978). Pochatky ukrainskoi bohoslovskoi nauky v dvadtsiatomu stolittiu i Blazheniishyi Patriarkh Yosyf [The beginnings of Ukrainian theology in the twentieth century and His Beatitude Patriarch Joseph], Rome, 56 s. (in Ukr.).
28. Naukovi zapysky Ukrainskoho Katolytskoho Universytetu Seriia: Bohoslovia [Analecta of the UCU. Series: Theology]. Retrieved from https://nztheology.ucu.edu.ua/en/. (in Ukr.).
29. Naukovo-Bohoslovskyi Zhurnal Svitylnyk («Candela») [Scientific and Theological Journal Svitylnyk («Candela»)]. Retrieved from http://cpbi. info/journal/. (in Ukr.).
30. Pro zatverdzhennia Poriadku formuvannia Pereliku naukovykh fakhovykh vydan Ukrainy. Redaktsiia vid 16.02.2021 [About the statement of the Order of formation of the List of scientific professional editions of Ukraine. Edited by 16.02.2021]. Retrieved from https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/ show/z0148-18#Text. (in Ukr.).
31. Radchenko, A. I. (2018). Novi vymohy do naukovykh fakhovykh vydan – krok u shyrokyi svit? [New requirements for scientific professional publications – a step into the wider world?], Nauka Ukrainy u svitovomu informatsiinomu prostori, Kyiv, vyp. 15, s. 91–98. (in Ukr.).
32. Radchenko, A. I. (2012). Pro naukovyi zhurnal, VAK Ukrainy ta naukometrychni systemy (do pytannia pro vymohy do naukovykh periodychnykh fakhovykh vydan) [About the scientific journal, the Higher Attestation Commission of Ukraine and scientometric systems (on the issue of requirements for scientific periodicals)], Nauka Ukrainy u svitovomu informatsiinomu prostori, vyp. 6, s. 45—52. (in Ukr.).
33. Redaktsiia (1932). Nashe desiatylittia [Our decade], Bohosloviia, t. I, kn. 1, s. 2–6. (in Ukr.).
34. Skruten, I., o. Yosafat OSBM. (1924). Preface, Analecta Ordinis S. Basilii Magni, t. I, s. 5–10. (in Ukr.).
35. Skruten, Y. (1924). Konstytuuiuchi zbory Bohoslovskoho Naukovoho T-va [Constituent Assembly of the Theological Scientific Society], Bohosloviia, t. II, kn. 1, s. 83–84. (in Ukr.).
36. Snitsarchuk, L. V. (2009). Ukrainska presa Halychyny (1919–1939 rr.) i zhurnalistykoznavchyi dyskurs: monohrafiia [Ukrainian Press of Galicia (1919–1939) and journalistic discourse: monograph], Lviv, 416 s. (in Ukr.).
37. Tymish, L. I. (2001). Istoryko-tserkovni doslidzhennia mizhvoiennoho Lvova u zhurnali «Zapysky Chynu sv. Vasyliia Velykoho» [Historical and ecclesiastical studies of interwar Lviv in the journal Analecta Ordinis S. Ba silii Magni], Problemy humanitarnykh nauk: zb. nauk. pr. DDPU imeni Ivana Franka, Drohobych, no. 8, s. 166–175, seriia: Istoriia. (in Ukr.).
38. Tymoshyk, M. (2014). Vydavnytstvo ottsiv Vasylian u Rymi: spetsyfika vydan ta osoblyvosti redaktsiino-vydavnychoho protsesu [The Basilian Fathers’ Publishing House in Rome: Specifics of Publications and Peculiarities of the Editorial and Publishing Process], Zapysky Lvivskoi natsionalnoi naukovoi biblioteky Ukrainy imeni V. Stefanyka, Lviv, vyp. 6, s. 294– 310. (in Ukr.).
39. Khodak, I. (2009). Rol bohoslovskoho naukovoho tovarystva u rozvytku bohoslovskoi nauky u 20–30 rr. XX st. [The role of the theological scientific society in the development of theological science in 20–30 pp. XX century], Zapysky istorychnoho fakultetu, vyp. 20, s. 183–187. (in Ukr.).
40. Khorkava, I. I. (2019). Uchast profesorsko-pedahohichnoho kolektyvu Hreko-katolytskoi bohoslovskoi akademii v roboti Bohoslovskoho naukovho tovarystva u Lvovi vprodovzh 1920 – poch. 1940 rr. [Participation of the teaching staff of the Greek Catholic Theological Academy in the work of the Theological Scientific Society in Lviv during 1920 – early 1940], Vcheni zapysky Tavriiskoho natsionalnoho universytetu imeni V. I. Vernadskoho, Kyiv, t. 30(69), no. 3, 224 s., seriia: Istorychni nauky. (in Ukr.).
41. Tsentralnyi derzhavnyi istorychnyi arkhiv Ukrainy, m. Lviv (dali – TsDIAU, m. Lviv), f. 376 (Skruten Y. (1894–1951), sviashchennyk ChSVV, istoryk tserkvy), op. 1, spr. 9 (Lyst O. Nazaruka do [o. Y. Skrutenia]), ark. 27.
42. TsDIAU, m. Lviv, f. 376 (Skruten Y. (1894–1951), sviashchennyk ChSVV, istoryk tserkvy), op. 1, spr. 90 (Lyst Vasyliia [Ladyky] ChSVV do [o. Y. Skrutenia]), ark. 10.
43. TsDIAU, m. Lviv, f. 376 (Skruten Y. (1894–1951), sviashchennyk ChSVV, istoryk tserkvy), op. 1, spr. 101 (Lyst L[iny] Malytskoi do [o. Y. Skrutenia]), ark. 12.
44. TsDIAU, m. Lviv. f. 376 (Skruten Y. (1894–1951), sviashchennyk ChSVV, istoryk tserkvy), op. 1, spr. 155 (Lyst O. Florovskoho do [o. Y. Skrutenia]), ark. 42.
45. TsDIAU, m. Lviv, f. 376 (Skruten Y. (1894–1951), sviashchennyk ChSVV, istoryk tserkvy), op. 1, spr. 165 (Lyst V. Shchurata do [o. Y. Skrutenia]), ark. 16.
46. Chekhovych, K. (1932). Zahalni Zbory B.N.T. [General Meeting of BNT], Bohosloviia, t. X, kn. 1, s. 90. (in Ukr.).
47. Yatskiv, T. M. (2017). Kryterii otsinky naukovoho zhurnalu tsyfrovyi identyfikator DOI yak kryterii otsinky naukovoho zhurnalu [Criteria for evaluating a scientific journal digital identifier of the DOI as a criterion for evaluating a scientific journal], Nauka Ukrainy u svitovomu informatsiinomu prostori, Kyiv, s. 106–113. (in Ukr.).
48. Benedictus PP. XV. Motu Proprio Dei Providentis De Instituto Pontificio Studiis Rerum Orientalium Provehendis. Retrieved from https://www.vatican.va/content/benedict-xv/la/motu_proprio/documents/hf_ben-xv_motu-proprio_19171015_orientis-catholici.html. (in Lat.).
49. Benedictus PP. XV. Motu Proprio Dei Providentis De Sacra Congregatione Pro Ecclesia Orientali. Retrieved from https://www.vatican.va/content/ benedict-xv/la/motu_proprio/documents/hf_ben-xv_motu-proprio_19170501_dei-providentis.html. (in Lat.).
50. Polkinghorne, J. (1998). Science and Theology, pp. 20–22. (in Eng.).
51. Pope Pius XI. Rerum Orientalium On the Promotion of Oriental Studies. Retrieved from https://www.papalencyclicals.net/pius11/p11reror.htm. (in Eng.).
52. (1926). Pro domo nostra, Zapysky ChSVV, t. 2, ch. 1/2, pp. 149. (in Ukr.).